ZERO POINT

ZP Publications
Recent Articles
Event Schedule
About the Author
Z P Dynamics

Psychological Illusions


Section I V

2b.  Negative Emotions

"So if one is trying to create consciousness, 
one must at the same time struggle with negative emotions, 
for either you keep them or you develop
–you cannot have both together."   
(Ouspensky, 1957, p.75)

    The fourth way offers a dismal view of the role of negative emotions within the life of humanity.  Negative emotions are a central and pervasive feature of human abnormality and pathology.  Ouspensky states that there are “no necessary negative emotions.” Negative emotions are never justified, never useful, never productive, never glorious and noble.  Instead, negative emotions are useless, and waste the energies of the emotional life as well as those of the other centers.  The fourth way psychology highlights the extent to which negative emotions govern the sleepwalking life of humanity, and the horror of this situation.
    There are innumerable types of negative states and emotions: anger, hostility, envy, boredom, depression, anxiety and worry, resentments, suspicion, fear, self-pity, annoyance, jealousy, mistrust, emotions of violence, and so on and on.  Ouspensky describes negative emotions as a terrible phenomena, which solve nothing, yield no knowledge, make life a burden and result in the great violence and suffering of humankind.  Even worse is the fact that people do not realize that negative emotions are something which might be questioned, or struggled with in order to eliminate.
    People even imagine that they control their negative emotions, manifesting them as they like, or as they choose, and that negative emotions express their real self, or I.  Humans in the state of relative consciousness glorify negative states and take them to be motivating, or as providing catharsis, or as giving oneself life, vitality and purpose.  All of these rationalizations are simply wrong ideas which justify weaknesses and stupidity.  People do not choose their emotional reactions but are mechanically controlled by them.  In fact, as they are, people cannot stop the stream of habitual negative emotional reactions and states.
I want particularly to draw your attention to this idea of negative emotions and the state of negative emotion.  ... It is necessary to realize that there is not a single useful negative emotion, useful in any sense.  Negative emotions are all a sign of weakness.  Next, we must realize that we can struggle with them; they can be conquered and destroyed because there is no real center for them.  If they had a real center, like instinctual emotions, there would be no chance; we would remain for ever in the power of negative emotions.  So it is lucky for us that they have no real center; it is an artificial center that works, and this artificial center can be abolished.  When this is done, we will feel much better for it.  Even the realization that it is possible is very much, but we have many convictions, prejudices and even ‘principles’ about negative emotions, so it is very difficult to get rid of the idea that they are necessary.  Try to think about it ….  (1957, pp.69-70)
Negative emotions are artificial–with no real center.  Instead, they have an artificial center in the formatory mind, and the wrong attitudes and beliefs of the many different little i’s which make up false personality.  Ouspensky explains:
... false personality … is, so to speak, a special organ for negative emotions, for displaying, enjoying and producing them.  You remember that there is no real center for negative emotions.  False personality acts as a center for them. (1957, pp. 173-174)
Negative emotions are based upon patterns of conditioning, mistaken ideas and incorrect thinking, negative imagination and states of identification.  Typically, we regard negative emotions as being justified reactions to external conditions; they are caused by someone or something else.  In this way, humans misunderstand the essential nature of negative emotions, and fail to recognize that they are simply conditioned reactions and patterns of false personality.  From this perspective, negative emotions are expressions of our weaknesses, our imaginary concerns and compulsions, our lack of true consciousness.
    Modern culture consistently reinforces and glorifies negative emotions: portraying them as being not only appropriate, but justifiable and honorable reactions to any and all situations.  Educators, parents, peers and the media suggest that negative emotions can be right or noble, genuine expressions of one real self.  Even psychotherapists share this view–believing that anger and worrying are, to a certain extent, natural, useful and appropriate processes. All in all, people cling to negative emotions and celebrate them.  Consequently, they cannot even imagine why they would want to oppose their negative emotions and seek to be less attached to their expression.
    Of course, there is only one way to verify the view that negative emotions are unnecessary, wasteful and useless, and that is to study oneself.  Unfortunately, the study of negative emotions is very difficult to do in an impartial way and people little motivation for controlling their manifestations.   Nicoll (1975) explains:
...  we identify with our emotions more than with anything else and so I repeat, we take our emotional state always for granted–not as something that we have to observe and separate from.  Everyone has a typical series of constantly recurring emotional states which vary from the greatest excitement and enthusiasms to the most depressed and morbid feelings.  But because the force of the emotions is so blinding people remain fixed on the turning wheel of their emotions.  In other words, people do not distrust their emotions but take them as if they were genuine and quite real states.  They accept their emotions as right at any particular moment.  And because emotions are so difficult to observe, owing to our tendency to identify with them, they do not observe them as something to observe and not go with.  The starting-point always lies in self-observation … The effort of internal attention will then begin to separate you from the emotional state and you may be able thereby to disarm it–i.e. not go with it, not believe in it, not take it for granted. (p. 811)
    There are various practices which aid the struggle against negative emotions.  Firstly, there must be a conscious effort to observe and study negative emotions by becoming aware of them as they arise within one’s inner life.   Without making an effort  to study oneself, a person is simply carried along by negative feelings whenever they occur.  People are normally fused with these states and identified with them.  Negative emotions control and enslave people–yet they have no objective view of how this all happens.  In order to begin to free ourselves from the unconscious rule of negative emotions, we must objectively see what they are–what they arise from in us and what value or role they have in life. The first practice in thus self-observation and self-study.
   A second aspect to the study of negative emotions involves the struggle with identification.  Typically, we tend to identify “I” with “it,” to lose ourselves in negative emotions, imagination and internal considering, and to be absorbed in these processes.  The Buddhist view of attachment as the root cause of all sufferings, may be likened to the process of identification. We are attached to our  negative states and absorbed by these sub-identities, or little i’s.  However, by observing and remembering ourselves, one tries to inwardly separate from one’s negative states and to maintain a deeper sense of one’s presence within the fullness of the moment.  In this case, there is an inward separation between I and it–even if only slightly or momentarily, before one gets caught up again in the patterns of personal concerns.
    Insights into patterns of negative states help to de-automatize these processes, as one loosens the attachment and identification.  In doing so, one aims to lessen such destructive patterns formed in false personality.   M. Nicoll compares this to tending a garden and getting rid of the weeds which would overtake the vegetables.  Similarly, observation and awareness of negative states begins to weaken the continual states of attachment and identification, allowing one to remove the weeds of negative states from one’s inner life.
   A third practice is the forming of the right mental attitudes, or right thinking. Ouspensky notes:
We have to begin with right understanding, right attitude.  As long as we think negative emotions are unavoidable, or even useful for self-expression, or something like that, we can do nothing.  A certain mental struggle is necessary to realize that they have no useful function in our life and that at the same time all life is based on them.  (1957, p. 70)
It is necessary to prepare the ground for the study of negative emotions by creating right attitudes and understanding.  Ouspensky comments:  “… mental work comes first.” (1957, p. 70)  One must take the idea that negative emotions are destructive and unnecessary and try to understand these principles through the process of self-study.  Negative emotions can be viewed from an impartial perspective: questioning their usefulness and justification; seeing one’s indulgences and pleasure in them; and examining them afterwards when one is less identified.   Each person has individual work to do in identifying their particular patterns of negative feelings and states.
    It is necessary to have the idea of struggling with negative emotions and then to apply this within self-study and inner work.  A person can think rightly at the times of negative emotions and be aware of what they really involve within oneself and the situation.  The origin of negative states must be understood within oneself, rather than simply being viewed as caused by others, or situational and accidental occurrences.  The light of consciousness and self-remembering begin to illuminate what negative emotions really entail, and their useless and unnecessary nature.
    A fourth aspect to the study of negative emotions involves the rule of not expressing them.  In order to understand what negative emotions entail–their mechanicalness and control over the person–it is necessary to struggle with their expression, both inwardly and outwardly.  One must see through work i’s, or work ideas, at times of negative emotions.  We must come to know how negative emotions move, think, feel, smell and taste, how we justify them, and in what weaknesses or past conditioning they are formed.  By  self-observing, the individual begins to separate I from “it, ” through increased consciousness.  Moments of non-identification bring about deeper insights, new emotional states, and gradually, an increased inner light or illumination.
    The study of negative emotions requires a resistance to negative states and reactions and their hold upon oneself.  This is not simply to restrict the outward expression of the emotion, while feeding it internally with justification, negative imagination and internal considering.  Repression or suppression only maintains negative emotions at a deeper subconscious level.  One has to find reasons and a viewpoint which demonstrate why negative emotions are unnecessary–understanding what these states involve from different angles and from the perspective of work ideas.  Most importantly, one needs to self-remember at times of negative emotions to enhance one’s consciousness of all that they involve.  One comes to view negative emotions as mechanical and automatized reactions of “it,” rather than as expressing real I.
    Negative emotional patterns are acquired throughout childhood and form patterns of false personality.  A child imitates other people and their emotional displays.  He or she learns manners of expression, feelings and imaginations, which support the identification with negative emotions.  A child also learns to control and manipulate others through the display of negative emotions, and can maintain a false exterior in order to hide inner feelings and insecurities.  Family, peers, socializing agents and cultural models all provide potential influences for imitation.  Children observe other people’s negative emotions and are the victims of them.  Unfortunately, over time, people come to think that their negative emotions comprise their real self.  Negative emotions assume control of the thinking center and motivate self-justification and internal considering.   To make matters worse, the inclinations of false personality towards laziness and self indulgence provide no basis for a struggle with negative states within oneself.
   All of these things need to be studied and verified within oneself, and doing so requires an exertion of conscious effort to observe and struggle with these states.  This cannot simply be done as an intellectual task–dealing with negative emotions in the abstract.  Instead, it is necessary to observe one’s particular states; to label and classify them;  to recognize their smell, taste, and walk;  to realize where they originate.  This all needs to be done in a personal way.  Ouspensky writes:  “You must find which negative emotions you chiefly have, why they come, what brings them, and so on.”  (1957, p.73)
    It is useful to study negative emotions within three spheres of life; within oneself by means of self-study and self-observation; in others whose negative states are intertwined with one’s own; and within society and the larger world scene.  The fourth way teaching suggests that the world is largely governed by negative emotions, and the history of humanity provides ample testimony to their pervasive and destructive nature.  Little by little,  one can begin to understand more objectively what negative emotions entail, of what stuff they are made and how they detract from life. It is necessary to acquire a new perspective, and to bring light to bear within the inner world–to realize how insane you have been.
    Negative emotions drain vital life energies, diminish consciousness and disrupt the harmonious development of an individual’s essence.  They are useless–yet they govern the life of sleepwalking humanity, and maintain human lunacy and madness:
So if one is trying to create consciousness, one must at the same time struggle with negative emotions, for either you keep them or you develop–you cannot have both together.   (Ouspensky, 1957, p.75)
The fourth way presents a dismal view of humanity asleep, ruled by negative emotions and self-love.  Tragically, from this viewpoint, people know little of the broader positive emotional states that emerge with moments of awakening.
Back to table of contents for Psychological Illusions
ZP Publications
Recent Articles
Event Schedule
About the Author
Z P Dynamics

Return home, through a zero point!